If a candidate needs money to be heard, how much of an election is really about ideas — and how much is about the ability to get those ideas in front of voters?
It is a difficult question because campaign spending is not automatically corrupt. Candidates need to communicate. Voters need information. Campaigns cost money, and transparent donations can be a legitimate part of political participation.
But the scale and sources of spending matter.
A report published by the Brennan Center for Justice in May 2025 estimated that groups not required to disclose their donors spent more than $1.9 billion in the 2024 US federal election cycle. The report described this as a record for so-called dark money in federal races.
That figure does not establish that a particular policy was bought, or that every donor expected a favour. It does, however, illustrate how much money can enter an electoral contest without voters necessarily knowing who supplied it.
There is a structural issue here. Candidates must attract attention, build organisations, communicate messages and compete with opponents. Fundraising becomes one of the activities around which modern campaigns are organised. Even a candidate who would prefer to spend every waking hour discussing policy has to operate within that competitive environment.
Now consider a different method of selecting people to deliberate on public questions.
In sortition, participants are selected by lot from the population, usually with safeguards to create a broadly representative group. They don’t need to raise campaign funds, buy advertising or persuade a party to nominate them. They are selected to take part, not to win a contest.
That removes one particular pressure: the need to finance a campaign for the role.
It does not remove every risk. Participants could still be influenced by powerful interests, biased information or unequal access to expertise. A citizens’ assembly needs transparent funding, independent administration, balanced evidence and rules governing conflicts of interest. Random selection is not a magic shield against influence.
Still, it changes the starting point. Instead of asking who can assemble the strongest campaign, the process asks who should be included in a representative cross-section of the public.
The distinction is explored in *The Answer*, Kizzi Nkwocha’s book on sortition and the argument that electoral competition can create incentives that are difficult to separate from the business of governing.
The question isn’t whether political campaigns should be allowed to spend money. It’s whether the people who make public decisions should have to win a money-intensive competition before they are allowed anywhere near the decision-making table.
How much campaign spending is compatible with political equality — and could randomly selected citizen bodies reduce the influence of money without creating new problems?
Book: https://www.amazon.com/Answer-Sortition-Rebuild-Broken-Politics/dp/B0G6FRDMJ1/
#CampaignFinance, #PoliticalMoney, #Democracy, #Sortition, #PoliticalReform, #CitizensAssemblies, #Transparency, #Governance, #PoliticalEquality, #TheAnswer
Want more like this?
Get an occasional email when there’s something new worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to receive occasional emails about new releases. Unsubscribe anytime by replying to any email.
